First graduate from the lab

So, my first M.S. student successfully defended her thesis today. She worked very hard and made some major progress on her abilities in the lab and writing department, and had a nice package of results with which to complete her MS degree. Her ideas and preliminary work have set the basis for a new direction for our group that got us a one-year internal pilot grant, and could turn out to be an interesting and fruitful direction for our technology. I'm really proud of her.

I also learned a lot about my role as a committee chair before and during a defense. Apparently I CAN jump in and guide the discussion, but I wasn't aware of that and kept my mouth shut at some points where I could have clarified or reworded the questions to help her understand what she was being asked, so our discussion got a little long and drawn out on some more general issues. Fortunately my two faculty mentors were on the committee, so they were able to give me some guidance on it afterwards for next time I have to help run someone's defense (hopefully not for a few more years once my going-into-second-year Ph.D. students get to that point!).

6 thoughts on “First graduate from the lab

  1. Coolio!In our PhD thesis defenses, the thesis advisor is strongly discouraged from opening her mouth during the defense, other than to deliver the encomium that kicks off the public seminar portion.

  2. They told me that here usually the thesis committee chair guides the discussion by finding out 2-3 main issues each committee member wants to talk about and making sure everyone gets a timely, efficient chance to rotate through and ask the candidate about them. Then makes sure the discussion gets some closure within an hour, so it doesn't drag on and on.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *